
Gartner CLM Magic Quadrant and Forrester Wave: The Latest Results (2026)
The latest Gartner Magic Quadrant for Contract Life Cycle Management is the 2025 edition, published on 10 November 2025. As of 10 November 2026 there is no 2026 edition. Its Leaders included Agiloft, Ironclad, Malbek and Sirion. The latest Forrester Wave for the category is Q1 2025, where the Leaders included Agiloft, Icertis, Ironclad and Sirion. If you only need the names, that is the answer. The rest of this guide shows where each placement comes from, how the three analyst firms differ, and how much weight a report should carry in your own selection.
Transparency note: We build Bind, an AI workspace for in-house legal teams. We are too new and too small to appear in these analyst reports. Every placement below links to the vendor's own announcement or names the report, because the reports themselves are paywalled.
The Latest Gartner, Forrester and IDC Results at a Glance
| Report | Edition | Leaders included | Source for the placements |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gartner Magic Quadrant for Contract Life Cycle Management | 10 November 2025 | Agiloft, Ironclad, Malbek, Sirion | Announcements by Agiloft, Ironclad, Malbek, Sirion |
| Forrester Wave: Contract Lifecycle Management Platforms | Q1 2025 (12 vendors, 26 criteria) | Agiloft, Icertis, Ironclad, Sirion | Announcements by Agiloft, Icertis, Ironclad, Sirion |
| IDC MarketScape: Worldwide AI-Enabled Buy-Side CLM Applications | 2025 (June 2025) | Icertis, Sirion, ContractPodAi (now Leah) | Announcements by Icertis, Sirion, ContractPodAi |
These lists are not complete. They contain the vendors that publicly announced a Leader placement, which is how most buyers learn the results without buying the report. Agiloft, Ironclad and Sirion are the names that appear as Leaders in both the latest Gartner Magic Quadrant and the latest Forrester Wave.
One placement outside the Leaders quadrant is also on the record from the vendors themselves: Workday was placed as a Visionary. We could not confirm the 2025 Gartner placements of Icertis or Conga from Gartner or from the vendors, so we do not state them here.
Which Gartner Document Answers Which Question
Gartner publishes several CLM documents, and they get mixed up in search results. The Magic Quadrant places vendors on the ability to execute and completeness of vision grid. The companion Critical Capabilities report scores products against specific use cases, such as pre-signature and post-signature work, which is more useful if you know your use case. The Market Overview for Contract Life Cycle Management (May 2026) and the earlier Market Guide editions describe the market and how it is changing; they do not rank vendors on a grid. When someone quotes "Gartner says", ask which of these documents and which year.
Why Analyst Reports Matter (and Why They Don't)
Analyst reports from firms like Gartner, Forrester, and IDC carry significant weight in enterprise technology purchasing. Procurement teams reference them in RFPs. Executives ask "are they in the Magic Quadrant?" before approving budget. Vendors invest heavily in positioning within these reports.
This influence is not accidental. These firms employ analysts who spend thousands of hours researching markets, interviewing vendors, surveying customers, and evaluating technology. Their methodologies are structured and documented. At their best, analyst reports provide a useful framework for understanding a complex market.
But they also have limitations that buyers should understand before treating them as definitive. Analyst reports tend to favor large enterprises, evaluate vendors at a point in time rather than tracking trajectory, and involve financial relationships between the analyst firms and the vendors being evaluated. Understanding both the value and the limitations helps you use these reports as one input among many, not as a final answer.
The Business Context
For legal operations leaders and procurement teams, analyst reports serve a specific organizational function beyond research. They provide external validation that helps justify purchasing decisions to executive stakeholders. When a CFO asks "why this vendor?" being able to reference a Gartner Leader designation carries weight that internal analysis alone may not. This is practical reality, not endorsement. Use this dynamic strategically: analyst reports are excellent for building internal consensus, but they should not replace your own evaluation of fit, usability, and value.
The Three Major CLM Analyst Reports
Gartner Magic Quadrant for Contract Life Cycle Management
The Gartner Magic Quadrant is the most widely recognized analyst report in enterprise software. For CLM, it evaluates vendors on two axes: ability to execute (vertical) and completeness of vision (horizontal). This creates four quadrants.
| Quadrant | What It Means |
|---|---|
| Leaders | Strong execution and broad vision. Typically the largest, most established vendors. |
| Challengers | Strong execution but narrower vision. Reliably deliver but may not be innovating as aggressively. |
| Visionaries | Broad vision but weaker execution. Often newer platforms with ambitious roadmaps. |
| Niche Players | Focused on a specific segment or capability. Can be excellent for their target market. |
Gartner's evaluation criteria include product capabilities, market understanding, sales execution, customer experience, and viability. Vendors included in the MQ typically must meet minimum revenue thresholds and customer counts, which means the report naturally excludes smaller or newer platforms.
Gartner pairs the Magic Quadrant with a Critical Capabilities report that scores products against specific use cases rather than placing them on a grid. If your need is narrow, for example post-signature obligation tracking, the use case scores tell you more than the quadrant does.
Leaders in the 2025 Gartner Magic Quadrant for CLM (published 10 November 2025, the most recent edition) included Agiloft, Ironclad, Malbek and Sirion. Placements move between editions, so never rely on a placement quoted without its edition and year.
How to read it: Do not fixate on which quadrant a vendor occupies. Instead, read the accompanying prose for each vendor profile, which contains far more nuance than the dot placement. Pay particular attention to the "Cautions" section for each vendor, which describes weaknesses that the visual placement does not convey. A Leader with significant cautions around implementation complexity may be a worse choice for your team than a Niche Player with no cautions relevant to your situation.
Forrester Wave: Contract Lifecycle Management
The Forrester Wave uses a similar but distinct methodology. Vendors are evaluated and placed on a grid with four categories: Leaders, Strong Performers, Contenders and Challengers. The axes measure current offering strength (vertical) and strategy (horizontal). Circle size indicates market presence.
Key differences from Gartner:
- Forrester tends to include fewer vendors per Wave than Gartner includes in a Magic Quadrant
- The evaluation criteria weight innovation and strategy more heavily
- Forrester's research methodology involves more structured customer reference interviews
- Waves reappear less often than Magic Quadrants: the CLM Wave came out in Q2 2023 and Q1 2025
Forrester evaluates CLM vendors across criteria including contract authoring, clause management, negotiation workflows, analytics, AI capabilities, and integration depth. Recent Waves have placed significant weight on AI maturity and user experience design.
Wave placements: The latest edition is The Forrester Wave: Contract Lifecycle Management Platforms, Q1 2025, which evaluated the 12 most significant CLM vendors against 26 criteria, according to Ironclad's announcement. Its Leaders included Agiloft, Icertis, Ironclad and Sirion. The edition before it was Q2 2023, which evaluated 13 vendors.
How to read it: Forrester's scoring methodology is more granular than Gartner's. Look at the individual criterion scores in the detailed scorecard, not just the overall placement. A vendor might rank as a Strong Performer overall but score highest in the specific criteria that matter most to you, such as "ease of use" or "integration ecosystem." The strategy score is also worth examining: it indicates how well-positioned a vendor is for the future, not just where they stand today.
IDC MarketScape: Contract Life-Cycle Management
The IDC MarketScape is the least well-known of the three major reports but has been growing in influence, particularly among procurement and IT leadership. IDC uses a distinct methodology that maps vendors on two dimensions: capabilities and strategies.
What sets IDC apart is a greater emphasis on implementation experience and operational considerations. Their evaluations include more weight on deployment models, time-to-value, professional services quality, and customer retention. This makes IDC MarketScape reports particularly useful for buyers who are concerned about the practical realities of deploying and living with a CLM platform.
IDC splits the category more finely than Gartner or Forrester. Its 2025 assessments were buy-side reports: the IDC MarketScape: Worldwide AI-Enabled Buy-Side Contract Lifecycle Management Applications 2025 Vendor Assessment (June 2025), whose Leaders included Icertis, Sirion and ContractPodAi (now Leah), and a separate assessment of CLM within source-to-pay suites. The previous IDC report aimed at legal teams was the Worldwide Contract Life-Cycle Management Software for Corporate Legal 2024 Vendor Assessment. Check that the IDC report you are reading matches your side of the contract: a buy-side report evaluates procurement contracting, not sales contracts.
How to read it: IDC MarketScape reports are particularly useful if your primary concern is implementation success rather than feature breadth. The detailed vendor profiles include information about average implementation timelines, professional services requirements, and customer satisfaction that Gartner and Forrester cover less thoroughly. If you have been burned by a difficult software deployment in the past, IDC's perspective is worth seeking out.
Comparing the Three Methodologies
| Aspect | Gartner MQ | Forrester Wave | IDC MarketScape |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vendors covered | Most | Fewest | In between |
| How often it reappears | Most often | Less often | Less often |
| Primary axes | Execute vs. Vision | Offering vs. Strategy | Capabilities vs. Strategies |
| Enterprise bias | High | High | Moderate |
| Pricing included | Minimal | Some | More than others |
| Implementation focus | Low | Moderate | High |
None of the three firms publishes a list price or a guaranteed publication cadence, so the comparisons above are relative rather than numeric. Check each firm's own site for the current edition and what it costs.
What the 2025 Reports Say About AI, Integration and Adoption
Across the 2025 Gartner, Forrester and IDC evaluations, several themes come up consistently. These themes are worth understanding because they reflect where the market is heading, not just where it is today.
AI Is Becoming Mandatory, Not Optional
Every major analyst report now treats AI capabilities as a core evaluation criterion rather than a differentiator. Two years ago, having AI-powered contract review was enough to stand out. Today, analysts expect AI across the full lifecycle: drafting, clause suggestion, risk identification, obligation extraction, and analytics. The bar has moved from "has AI" to "has effective, reliable AI that users actually adopt."
This shift has important implications for buyers. It means that checking the "AI" box on an RFP is no longer sufficient. You need to evaluate how deeply AI is integrated, what training data it uses, how accurate it is for your contract types, and whether it actually reduces work or just adds a novelty feature.
Integration Depth Matters More Than Feature Count
Analysts are increasingly distinguishing between platforms that offer many features and platforms that integrate deeply into existing workflows. A CLM that connects to your CRM, ERP, and e-signature tools through robust APIs and pre-built connectors scores higher than one with more features but weak integration.
This reflects real-world deployment experience. The most common reason CLM implementations fail is not missing features. It is poor adoption, and poor adoption is frequently caused by the CLM sitting outside existing workflows rather than embedding within them.
Analysts are now evaluating integration along several dimensions: number of pre-built connectors, API quality and documentation, webhook support, and the ability to embed contract workflows within tools like Salesforce, Slack, or Microsoft Teams. For buyers, this means asking integration questions early in the evaluation, not as an afterthought. Our CLM implementation checklist covers integration planning in detail.
A newer question is whether the AI tools your team already uses can reach the contracts. In Bind's case, other systems send documents and field values in through the Bind API, a REST API with public documentation, and Bind MCP lets Claude or ChatGPT search and read contracts in Bind with each person's own login (read only). Both are included on every Bind plan; see how vendors compare in our CLM API access comparison.
User Adoption Is a Critical Differentiator
All three firms have increased the weight given to user experience and adoption metrics in their evaluations. Ease of use for non-legal stakeholders and time-to-competency for new users now feature in CLM evaluation criteria in ways they did not a few years ago.
This trend favors platforms built with business users in mind, not just legal power users. Sales teams, procurement managers, and HR professionals all interact with contracts. If these stakeholders cannot use the CLM without extensive training, adoption stalls.
One concrete signal: Ironclad's announcement of its Forrester Q1 2025 Leader placement highlights top marks on usability, alongside contract digitization and reporting. Usability is now a scored criterion, not an afterthought.
Pricing Transparency Is Improving, But Slowly
Analyst reports have historically paid limited attention to pricing, and that is beginning to change: pricing transparency and total cost of ownership now appear as evaluation factors where they once did not, and IDC's MarketScape methodology has long included pricing considerations. Check the methodology section of whichever edition you are reading to see exactly how much weight it carries.
Despite this progress, most analyst reports still do not include actual pricing figures. They evaluate whether pricing is transparent and predictable, but they leave the specific numbers for buyers to discover during the sales process. For actual pricing data, our CLM pricing guide provides more direct comparisons.
The Mid-Market Is Where the Movement Is
The CLM mid-market was historically underserved by vendors who focused on large enterprise deals. That is visibly changing: platforms purpose-built for mid-market needs are gaining traction, and enterprise vendors are creating simplified editions to compete.
We are not attaching a growth rate to that observation, because the segment-level growth figures that circulate are either paywalled or untraceable. What you can verify yourself is the product evidence: more accessible published pricing, self-serve deployment models, and vendors explicitly naming mid-sized teams as their target buyer.
CLM Vendor Positioning Across Analyst Reports
The table below lines up the placements that are on the public record for the latest Gartner and Forrester editions. A dash means we found no announcement from the vendor or the analyst firm, not that the vendor was left out.
| Vendor | Gartner MQ for CLM, Nov 2025 | Forrester CLM Wave, Q1 2025 | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agiloft | Leader | Leader | Known for no-code configurability. Says 2025 was its sixth year in a row as a Gartner Leader. |
| Ironclad | Leader | Leader | Third year in a row as a Gartner Leader, by its own announcement. |
| Malbek | Leader | Not announced | Enterprise CLM with a strong integration story. |
| Sirion | Leader | Leader | Fourth year in a row as a Gartner Leader, by its own announcement. Strong in post-signature obligation management. |
| Icertis | Not announced | Leader | Built for large, complex global deployments. Also an IDC Leader in 2025. |
| Workday | Visionary | Not announced | Contract management inside the Workday suite. |
| SpotDraft | Not included | Not included | Focused on mid-market legal teams. |
| Concord | Not included | Not included | Published flat pricing: Essentials at $499 a month for 5 users, billed annually (Concord pricing). |
| Bind | Not included | Not included | Too new for analyst coverage. AI workspace for in-house legal teams: drafting, review, negotiation, e-signature and contract management. |
Placements are from the vendors' own announcements of the Gartner Magic Quadrant for Contract Life Cycle Management (10 November 2025) and The Forrester Wave: Contract Lifecycle Management Platforms, Q1 2025, checked on 10 November 2026. Verify against the current report before relying on any of them.
How to Use Analyst Reports in Your CLM Evaluation
Analyst reports are valuable research tools when used correctly. The mistake is treating them as a shortcut to a decision rather than as one input in a broader evaluation process.
- Use reports to build initial awareness of the market landscape
- Identify 5-8 vendors that match your size and requirements
- Ignore quadrant placement and read the detailed vendor profiles
- Cross-reference analyst findings with peer reviews on G2 and Gartner Peer Insights
- Run your own evaluation with demos, trials, and reference calls
Four Blind Spots in Analyst Reports
Enterprise bias is real. Most analyst reports evaluate vendors against enterprise requirements: complex approval workflows, global deployment, advanced compliance features, extensive integrations. If you are a mid-market company, many of these criteria are irrelevant to your situation. A vendor rated as a "Niche Player" for lacking enterprise features might be perfectly suited to your needs.
Vendor participation is not free. Vendors typically pay fees to participate in analyst evaluations, including licensing fees for using the resulting graphics in their marketing. This does not mean the evaluations are biased, as analyst firms maintain research independence rigorously. But it does mean that the pool of evaluated vendors skews toward those with marketing budgets large enough to participate. Smaller or bootstrapped vendors are often absent simply because they have not engaged with the analyst firm.
Feature counts can mislead. Analyst evaluations necessarily compress complex capabilities into scores and ratings. A vendor might score highly on "AI capabilities" because they offer many AI features, even if individual features are shallow or unreliable. The detailed prose in each vendor profile is far more useful than the summary scores.
Your requirements may differ from analyst criteria. Analyst firms define evaluation criteria based on what the broad market needs. Your specific requirements might emphasize areas that receive low weight in the analyst methodology, or de-emphasize areas that receive high weight. Always map the evaluation criteria to your actual priorities.
- Which vendors meet enterprise requirements
- Market trends and direction
- Vendor financial viability
- Feature breadth across the lifecycle
- Relative positioning among large vendors
- Which vendor is best for YOUR specific needs
- Actual pricing and total cost of ownership
- Day-to-day user experience and support quality
- Implementation difficulty and time-to-value
- How the platform performs with YOUR contract types
CLM Market Trends Behind the Latest Reports
Beyond individual vendor evaluations, analyst reports reveal broader market trends that affect all buyers. Understanding these trends helps you evaluate not just where vendors are today, but where the market is heading over the next two to three years. These trends are consistent across all three major analyst firms, which increases confidence that they represent genuine market shifts rather than individual analyst opinions.
AI-Native CLM Is Rising
There is a growing distinction between platforms that integrated AI into an existing architecture and platforms built with AI as a foundational capability. Both approaches can work well: several established suites have integrated AI deeply over successive releases, while newer platforms started from AI as the primary interface. AI-native platforms tend to weave AI into every workflow rather than offering it as a separate module.
For buyers, the practical question is not which architecture a vendor claims but whether the AI features feel like a natural part of the workflow or like a separate tool you must context-switch into. Test that with your own contracts rather than taking either side's framing at face value. For more on this distinction, see our guide on AI-native contract management.
Vendor Consolidation Is Accelerating
The CLM market has seen significant acquisition activity. Larger vendors are acquiring specialized platforms to fill capability gaps, and private equity firms are rolling up smaller players. This consolidation affects buyers in several ways. Acquired products sometimes see reduced investment as they are integrated into larger platforms. Integration between acquired products can be rough in the near term. On the positive side, consolidation can create more comprehensive platforms and improve financial stability.
For buyers, consolidation raises practical questions: Will the product you buy today still exist as a standalone platform in three years? Will the team that built it still be running it? Will pricing change after acquisition? Analyst reports sometimes flag acquisition risk, but you should also research vendor ownership, funding history, and recent M&A activity independently. A venture-backed startup with aggressive growth targets and a private-equity-owned platform undergoing integration carry different risk profiles.
Self-Serve Deployment Is Growing
Traditional CLM deployments involved a scoped professional services engagement, dedicated implementation teams, and extensive customization. A growing number of platforms now offer self-serve deployment, where standing the platform up is something the buying team does itself rather than a project the vendor delivers. Analyst reports are beginning to evaluate time-to-value and deployment complexity more explicitly, reflecting buyer demand for faster implementations.
This trend is especially relevant for mid-market teams that lack the internal resources to manage a scoped implementation project. The ability to sign up, configure basic workflows, import templates, and start drafting contracts without a vendor engagement has gone from a nice-to-have to a competitive requirement in this segment.
Price Compression Is Beginning
Increased competition and the rise of AI-native platforms built on modern architectures are putting downward pressure on CLM pricing, particularly in the mid-market. Platforms that previously sold only through an enterprise sales motion are introducing lower-tier plans, and new entrants are launching with published prices well below them. The verifiable evidence for this is on the vendors' own pricing pages: PandaDoc publishes from $19/user/month on annual billing, Concord publishes $499 a month for 5 users on annual billing, and Bind publishes $90 per user a month billed annually. This trend benefits buyers but also raises questions about vendor sustainability at lower price points.
The pricing shift is also changing how vendors package their products. Monthly billing, usage-based pricing, and per-seat models are becoming more common alongside traditional annual enterprise contracts. For mid-market buyers, this means more options and lower barriers to entry. For enterprise buyers, it means more negotiating leverage. For a detailed comparison of what each vendor actually charges, see our CLM pricing guide.
Choosing a CLM Beyond Analyst Reports
Analyst reports should inform your evaluation, not determine it. Here is a practical framework for making a CLM decision that goes beyond what any analyst report can provide.
The core principle is straightforward: analyst reports tell you about the market. Only you can determine what works for your team, your contracts, and your budget. The following steps move from analyst-informed research to hands-on evaluation, which is where real purchasing confidence comes from.
Run a Proof of Concept With Your Actual Contracts
The single most valuable evaluation step is testing platforms with your real contracts. Not a vendor's demo contracts. Not a scripted scenario. Your actual NDAs, MSAs, SOWs, or whatever contract types drive the majority of your volume. A platform that looks impressive in a demo may struggle with your specific contract language, clause structures, or approval workflows.
Request a trial or sandbox environment and upload 10-20 representative contracts. Test the workflows your team will use daily: drafting from templates, redlining, approval routing, and search. Time how long each step takes and compare against your current process. If a vendor will not provide a trial or POC, that itself is useful information.
Talk to Actual Users, Not Just Vendor References
Vendor-supplied references are pre-selected to tell positive stories. Supplement these with independent research: G2 and Gartner Peer Insights reviews, LinkedIn connections who use the platform, legal operations communities like CLOC or ACC, and direct outreach to companies similar to yours. The questions that matter most are about daily usability, support responsiveness, and whether the platform delivered the value promised during the sales process.
Specific questions to ask current users:
- How long did implementation actually take compared to what was quoted?
- What was the biggest surprise after deployment?
- How responsive is support when things break?
- Would you choose this platform again knowing what you know now?
- What features do you use daily versus what sounded good in the demo but you never touch?
These conversations will tell you more about the day-to-day experience than any analyst report or demo.
Calculate Total Cost of Ownership, Not Just License Cost
For an enterprise CLM, the license fee is only part of the first-year bill. Implementation, training, integrations, data migration, and ongoing support make up the rest. For a detailed breakdown of what CLM platforms actually cost, see our CLM pricing guide. When evaluating, always ask vendors for a three-year total cost projection that includes all fees, not just the initial quote.
Common costs that are not included in license quotes:
- Implementation and configuration, which self-serve platforms include and enterprise vendors quote as a separate professional services engagement (ask for the rate card and the scope in writing)
- Data migration from your current system or file storage
- Initial onboarding and ongoing training for new team members
- Integrations with CRM, ERP, HRIS or other business systems
- Premium support for faster response times or a dedicated account manager
- Add-on modules for analytics, AI features or advanced compliance
Match Vendor to Your Actual Size
One of the most common CLM purchasing mistakes is buying a platform designed for a company five times your size. Enterprise CLM platforms come with enterprise complexity: longer implementations, more configuration requirements, steeper learning curves, and higher costs. If you have 200 employees and process 50 contracts per month, you do not need a platform built for a Fortune 500 company processing 10,000 contracts per month.
The analyst reports often make this harder, not easier. Because they evaluate primarily against enterprise criteria, the "Leaders" are almost always enterprise platforms. A mid-market company selecting a Leader based on analyst positioning often ends up overpaying for capabilities they will never use. Match your evaluation to your reality: your current team size, your current contract volume, and where you expect to be in two years, not ten.
Evaluate Support and Responsiveness
Analyst reports rarely capture support quality in meaningful detail. During your evaluation, test support directly. Submit a technical question through the vendor's support channel and measure response time. Ask about dedicated customer success resources. Find out whether support is included in the license price or requires an additional contract. For a platform your team will rely on daily, support quality often matters more than the fifth or sixth feature on your requirements list.
Related Resources
- CLM Pricing Guide 2026: What Every Tool Actually Costs: Actual pricing for every major CLM platform
- CLM Buying Guide: How to Evaluate and Choose the Right Tool: Step-by-step evaluation framework
- Best CLM Software for In-House Legal Teams: Focused comparison for in-house counsel
- What Is Contract Management Software?: Foundational overview of the CLM category
Trusted by fast-moving legal teams around the world
See how Bind would work for your team.
Book a demo
